Should you grade your Michael Jordan cards?
Grading can multiply a card's value — or barely cover its own cost. The difference comes down to three things: how valuable the card is, how sharp its condition is, and how big the premium is at the grade you're likely to get. Here's how to decide, and a tool to run your exact card.
Run the "Should I Grade?" tool →Enter your card's prices by grade and it does the math.
When grading is worth it
- The grade premium is large. If a PSA 10 of your card is worth many times the raw price, a gem-mint result more than pays for itself. This is the norm on key Jordan cards — see the jump across grades on the 1986 Fleer rookie.
- The card is genuinely sharp. Clean corners, good centering, no print lines or surface marks — a realistic shot at a 9 or 10.
- The card is worth enough. Grading fees are roughly fixed, so they eat a tiny slice of a $500 card and all of a $5 one.
When it isn't
- Low-value commons. If the raw and graded prices are close, the fee and shipping wipe out any gain.
- A visible flaw. One soft corner or off-centering can cap the card at an 8 — where the premium often doesn't cover grading at all.
- You need the cash now. Grading adds weeks (or months) and cost before you can sell.
The math (do this before you submit)
The decision is a simple comparison: (expected graded value − raw value) vs. (grading fee + shipping), weighted by the grade you'll realistically get. The trap is assuming a PSA 10; most "mint" raw cards come back a 9. OurShould I Grade? tool runs this for you — put in the card's price at each grade and your submission cost, and it tells you whether grading pays and at which grade it breaks even.
How to assess your card first
Graders score four things — check each under good light before deciding:
- Centering. Even borders front and back. Off-centering is the most common reason a card misses a 10.
- Corners. Sharp, not soft or frayed — the first thing to go with handling.
- Edges. Clean, no chipping or whitening (especially on dark borders).
- Surface. No scratches, print lines, or indentations; original gloss intact.
Which grader
For Jordan cards, PSA usually carries the deepest market and the strongest resale premium, which is why value guides (ours included) anchor to PSA. BGS and SGC are reputable alternatives — SGC is popular for vintage. Grade to whichever label the market pays the most for on your specific card, and check the card's price history by grade before you commit.
FAQ
Is it worth grading my Michael Jordan card?
It depends on the card's value, its condition, and the grade premium. Grading pays when a sharp, valuable card can jump to a PSA 9 or 10 — the premium far exceeds the fee. It rarely pays on low-value commons, or on cards with a flaw that caps them at a lower grade. Run the specific numbers before you submit.
How much does grading cost?
It varies by grader and service level — roughly $15–$30 per card at standard tiers, more for faster turnaround or high-value cards, plus shipping and insurance both ways. For a card worth a few dollars, that cost usually swamps any uplift.
What grade will my card get?
Graders score centering, corners, edges and surface. A card that looks "mint" to the eye often comes back a 9 because of slight off-centering or a tiny corner ding. Assume the realistic grade, not the best case, when you run the math.
PSA, BGS or SGC — which should I use?
PSA generally carries the deepest market and highest resale premiums for Jordan cards, which is why most value tables (ours included) anchor to PSA. BGS and SGC are reputable alternatives; for vintage, SGC is popular. Grade to the label the market pays the most for on your specific card.
Run your card through the numbers. Open the grade tool →
Educational only — not financial advice. Grading outcomes and values vary; our values are 23index market estimates (how we price).