Index methodology
23index calculates its own numbers, the market value of each card and the level of each index, rather than mirroring a single provider. Both are built to resist distortion from thin trading, a few expensive cards, or one odd day.
Market value
Every price on 23index is our calculated market value for that card and grade. We look at the recent daily prices, count a flat run of the same price once so it does not shrink the normal range, and drop a day that sits far outside that range. If the newest prices all sit on one side of the typical price for several days, that is a real move, and the value is taken from the days since the move. Recent days count more than older ones, so a new level shows up within days. One odd day still cannot reset the value.
Each value carries a confidence level (High, Medium, Low, or Low data), based on how many observations we have, how recent they are, and how much they scatter. It shows next to prices on card pages.
A grade that is still more than 25% away from its latest source price is held off Card of the week and the signals board until it is reviewed. BGS 10 is labeled Estimate when the price feed sets it at 1.3 times the PSA 10 price for that day. That figure is not a sale.
Index calculation
Each index is a set of member cards, priced on one grade (for example the 23 Market Index uses raw, ungraded prices). On the index's base date, every member is set equal to 1.0. On any later day the index level is:
index = base × average( pricetoday / pricebase ) across members
The base value is 1,000. So an index at 1,120 means that group of cards is up 12% on average since the base date.
Why equal-weighted
We average each card's relative change, not its price. That means a $3 card and a $55,000 card move the index by the same amount when each rises 10%. Expensive cards can't dominate the index, and cheap cards can't swing the percentage. The index reflects how the group is performing, not just its priciest members.
Guarding against distortion
- Single-day spikes are damped with a 3-day trailing median on each card's price, so one unusual reading doesn't move the index.
- Thin data is handled by only counting a card on days it has a valid price. A card with a gap simply sits out that day rather than distorting the level.
- Small samples post no value: a day needs a minimum number of priced members before the index records a level for it.
- Representation is tracked per day (how many member cards were included), and each index level carries a confidence level based on that coverage.
The indexes
23 Market Index tracks the broad Michael Jordan market on raw (ungraded) prices, across a wide set of cards. It answers: what is the overall Jordan market doing?
Jordan 23 is a curated benchmark of 23 iconic, actively traded cards at PSA 10, like a Dow for Jordan. It is not meant to represent every card, but the blue chips.
Signals
A signal is a momentum label on one card and grade, read from the change in its 23index value:
- Hot is up 8% or more over 7 days, Getting Hot up 3% or more, Cooling down 6% or more, otherwise Stable.
- Each reference price is a local median of nearby points, and any print more than 3x or less than 1/3 of the recent median is dropped first, so one odd sale cannot create a move.
- Low volume cards (fewer than our minimum sales over the last year) do not get a momentum label at all, because thin trading is not a trustworthy signal. They are left out of the signal sections.
- Not enough data yet means we do not have a reliable price from about a week ago to compare against.
Alongside the status, each card gets a plain-English call that reads the short-term (7-day) and longer-term (30-day) move together:
- Consider buying — down over the last week but still up over the month — a pullback inside an uptrend.
- Hold — no strong move either way; the price is holding steady.
- Wait to buy — falling over both the week and the month, so momentum is against buying right now.
- Consider selling — up hard over the week (and the month) — a strong run that may be stretched.
Not financial advice. Signals describe recent price movement only. They are not recommendations to buy or sell, and past movement does not predict future prices.
History is preserved
Index membership can change over time, and historical index values are never overwritten. As 23index accumulates data, these indexes become a long-run record of the Jordan card market.
This is version 1 of the methodology (eq-rel-v1). It will evolve as the underlying pricing engine and data coverage grow. Prices are guides, not guarantees.